politics
Deseret News Revives the 'Conservatives and Sex' Argument

Deseret News published an opinion piece this week carrying the headline "The truth about conservatives and sex," the kind of framing that promises a verdict and leaves the reader to find the receipts. The link is live on Deseret News, via Google News, and the piece sits in the "opinion" vertical, not news. That matters because "the truth" is a heavy word for a section built on argument rather than reporting.
What Does the Headline Actually Claim?
The title asserts a single, settled "truth" about an entire political coalition's intimate behavior. No subhead, data table, or named study accompanies the headline in the material available to this desk. That is not a knock on Deseret News, which has run serious religion-and-family coverage for decades. It is a flag for readers: a sweeping claim about "conservatives" as a bloc — tens of millions of people across denominations, regions, and income brackets — requires more than a thesis sentence to earn the word "truth." Until the underlying argument and its sourcing are laid out in full, the headline functions as a hook, not a finding.
Why Does This Particular Debate Keep Resurfacing?
Pieces framed around "what conservatives really do in private" are a recurring genre in American commentary, usually arriving in one of two flavors: a defense of traditional sexual ethics against accusations of hypocrisy, or an attack arguing that private behavior contradicts public rhetoric. Both versions depend on the same rhetorical move — treating a diverse coalition as a single behavioral unit. A conservative Southern Baptist in rural Alabama, a libertarian in Austin, and a Mormon family in Utah do not share a dating culture, a divorce rate, or a church attendance pattern just because they share a ballot choice. Collapsing them into one data point is the oldest trick in this particular op-ed subgenre, and it works because readers want a tidy story more than they want a caveat-filled one.
What Would It Actually Take to Prove a Claim Like This?
A defensible version of this argument would name its dataset, its survey years, its sample size, and its definition of "conservative" — self-identified, party-registered, or church-attending weekly. Absent that scaffolding, a claim about an entire political tendency's sexual behavior is an assertion dressed as a conclusion. This is a general epistemic problem with any op-ed that generalizes about a group's private conduct: self-reported survey data on sex is notoriously unreliable across every political and religious category, which is exactly why serious social scientists hedge their findings with margins of error and methodology notes rather than headline verdicts. An opinion piece that skips the hedge is asking for trust it has not earned.
Who Benefits When the Framing Stays Vague?
Vague, sweeping claims about a political tribe's private behavior serve the writer more than the reader. They generate clicks and arguments on social media without requiring the writer to defend a specific number against a specific critic. A reader who wants to actually litigate the claim has nothing to grab onto — no percentage, no year, no source to check. That is a weaker standard than this desk expects from itself, and it is a weaker standard than Deseret News has set in its own institutional coverage of family and faith issues over the years.
What Should Readers Demand From Pieces Like This?
Readers encountering a headline that promises "the truth" about any group's sex life should ask the piece to show its work before accepting the verdict. That is not cynicism; it is the same standard this desk applies to claims about federalism, judicial conduct, or any other politically charged assertion — a standard laid out in Quote Conservative's own guide to federalism, which argues that durable political claims need structural grounding, not just a confident headline. The same logic applies here. Conservatives, like any coalition of tens of millions, are not a single data point, and no single opinion essay — however well-intentioned — gets to declare "the truth" about their bedrooms without showing the receipts first.
Questions
What did the Deseret News opinion piece claim?
The piece ran under the headline "The truth about conservatives and sex," asserting a definitive claim about conservative sexual behavior; the specific data or argument behind that claim was not detailed in the material reviewed.
Is Deseret News a news report or an opinion piece on this topic?
The piece is labeled opinion, meaning it reflects the author's argument rather than Deseret News's news reporting standards.