politics
Madison — Where to Find Real Information on Judicial Candidates

Opinion. Wisconsin's Supreme Court decided this month to hold off on suspending the law license of Milwaukee Judge Hannah Dugan, a case that drew attention to how little most voters actually know about the people deciding it, according to Quote Conservative's report. That gap between high-stakes judicial power and low-information voters is precisely what State Court Report set out to address with a guide published this month, titled "Where To Learn About Judicial Candidates to Prepare to Vote in State Supreme Court Races," carried by Google News.
The premise behind the guide deserves scrutiny on its own terms. State supreme courts decide redistricting maps, abortion law, and election procedure across the country, frequently with less public attention than a city council race draws.
What prompted the guide?
State Court Report's headline frames the problem directly: voters heading into state supreme court elections often lack basic information about who is on the ballot, according to the outlet's report. The publication's focus on judicial candidates specifically, rather than judges already seated, suggests the gap it identified sits squarely at the ballot box.
Why do judicial races get so little scrutiny?
Unlike legislative or executive candidates, judicial candidates in most states cannot campaign on how they would rule in future cases under judicial conduct codes. That leaves voters to sort through bar ratings, past rulings, and finance disclosures — material that exists but rarely makes the evening news. Wisconsin's case is instructive: the dispute over Dugan's law license became national news only after a specific controversy forced it into view, not through routine coverage of her record.
Does federalism make this harder?
State court structures vary by state — some elect justices in partisan races, others in nonpartisan elections, still others through gubernatorial appointment and retention votes — a patchwork rooted in the same design examined in Quote Conservative's recent federalism explainer. There is no single national clearinghouse; voters in Wisconsin and voters elsewhere are working from different rulebooks entirely.
Why should this matter before Election Day, not after?
State supreme courts have the final word on most questions of state law, touching redistricting, ballot access, and sentencing in ways federal courts often cannot reach. A court that holds off on disciplining one of its own, as Wisconsin's did with Dugan, is still a court whose composition voters chose — or didn't bother to study before they voted.
Where should a voter actually start?
State Court Report's own existence as a resource is the clearest answer available: nonpartisan court-tracking outlets, state bar guides, and judicial conduct board records are the raw material voters need, even when they take more effort to find than a campaign mailer. Separately, concerns about ballot integrity detailed in HTT News' reporting on rising election fraud cases only raise the stakes on knowing who adjudicates those disputes in the first place.
The fix here is not complicated. It requires voters to spend a few minutes before an election doing what most skip entirely: reading who is actually on the ballot.
Questions
What did State Court Report publish about judicial candidates?
State Court Report published a guide titled "Where To Learn About Judicial Candidates to Prepare to Vote in State Supreme Court Races," aimed at helping voters find information before state supreme court elections, according to the report carried by Google News.
Why is it hard to find information on state supreme court candidates?
Judicial candidates in most states cannot campaign on how they would rule in future cases under judicial conduct codes, and court election systems vary by state, leaving voters to piece together bar ratings, past rulings, and disclosures on their own.