politics
Miami — Herald Board Backs Florida Supreme Court Retention

Opinion — Quote Conservative Commentary Desk
The Miami Herald's editorial board published a retention endorsement for Florida's Supreme Court justices this week, telling readers how to vote on a part of the ballot most Floridians skip entirely. The endorsement carries no individual byline beyond "Herald Editorial Board," and the full reasoning sits on the paper's own opinion page rather than in a press release or court filing. (Miami Herald via Google News)
That absence of a human byline is the point. Florida removed state Supreme Court justices from head-to-head campaigns decades ago in favor of up-or-down retention votes with no named opponent and almost no paid advertising. Editorial boards have filled that vacuum for years, arguing someone has to tell voters more than a judge's name before they mark a ballot.
How Does Florida's Supreme Court Retention Vote Work?
Florida voters don't pick Supreme Court justices in contested races. The governor appoints justices from a nominating commission's list, and those justices later face voters on a simple retain-or-remove question with no rival candidate on the ballot. That structure is why endorsements like the Herald's carry outsized weight: there's no opponent to counter the argument, no mailer laying out a competing record, just an up-or-down vote many voters encounter for the first time in the booth.
What Did the Herald's Editorial Board Say?
The Herald's opinion page frames the retention vote as a direct appeal to Florida voters, but the board's specific case for or against individual justices isn't broken out in the material available through the paper's own feed. Readers who want the full argument should read the Herald's opinion page directly rather than rely on a secondhand summary.
For broader context on why Florida structures judicial selection this way, HTT's own guide to federalism walks through how states diverge from the federal model on questions like this one.
Why Do Newspaper Boards Weigh In on Judges at All?
The case for editorial endorsements in retention races is straightforward: someone has to do the homework. Editorial boards that cover courthouses routinely read opinions, sit through oral argument, and talk to lawyers who appear before the justices in question — work most voters have no time to replicate before Election Day.
What's the Case Against Letting Editors Grade Judges?
The counterargument is just as old. Critics say newspapers substitute their own policy preferences for a judge's record on the law, and that a retention vote shaped by an opinion page risks politicizing a bench designed to sit above exactly that kind of pressure. Florida isn't alone in wrestling with where judicial accountability ends and politics begins: Wisconsin's Supreme Court this year held off on suspending Milwaukee judge Hannah Dugan's law license, a separate dispute that underscored how unevenly states handle the question of who watches sitting judges. (HTT News)
What to Watch
- Whether the Herald publishes its full reasoning and the specific justices covered by the endorsement.
- Whether other Florida newspapers issue competing or matching retention recommendations before voters decide.
- Whether Florida's ballot-driven retention model draws fresh comparison to states, like Wisconsin, that handle judicial discipline through the courts rather than the voting booth.