politics
Cato Institute Says Conservatives Shouldn't Fear Ranked Choice Voting

Opinion. The Cato Institute published a piece this week arguing that conservatives have no principled reason to oppose ranked choice voting, the ballot system that asks voters to rank candidates in order of preference rather than pick one. The headline states the thesis plainly: "Why Conservatives Shouldn't Fear Ranked Choice Voting." That framing deserves a fair hearing, and also a harder look than the headline alone provides.
What is ranked choice voting, and how does it work?
Under ranked choice voting (RCV), a voter orders candidates first, second, third, and so on instead of marking a single name. If no candidate wins a majority outright, election officials eliminate the last-place finisher and redistribute that candidate's votes to whoever each of those voters ranked next. The process repeats until one candidate clears 50 percent. Supporters, including the libertarian-leaning Cato Institute, describe this as a mechanism that rewards broad appeal over narrow factional wins.
What does the Cato Institute actually argue?
The available reporting on the piece is limited to its headline and framing, which positions RCV as a procedural reform rather than an ideological one. That framing is itself the argument: if RCV is just a counting method, the think tank's position implies, then resisting it is a tactical choice about who benefits, not a defense of any constitutional principle. Readers should note that this is the extent of what the sourced material establishes. The specific mechanics Cato cites to make that case are not available here, and this desk will not invent them.
"Why Conservatives Shouldn't Fear Ranked Choice Voting" — Cato Institute
Why have conservatives resisted ranked choice voting?
The resistance has generally rested less on fear of the counting method itself and more on who writes the rules and who administers them. Ballot design, tabulation software, and the order in which candidates are eliminated all sit in the hands of state and local election officials — the same officials conservatives have spent years scrutinizing over chain-of-custody and audit questions in conventional elections. Layering a new, more complex counting process onto that existing distrust is a harder sell than Cato's framing suggests, regardless of whether the method is neutral on paper.
There is also a practical objection that has nothing to do with ideology: RCV tabulation can take longer to certify than a simple plurality count, because officials may need multiple elimination rounds before a majority emerges. Whether that delay matters more than the stated benefit of avoiding spoiler candidates and vote-splitting is a legitimate disagreement, and Cato's piece appears to come down on one side of it.
Does federalism settle the fight over voting systems?
This is where Cato's argument and basic conservative constitutional theory actually align. States, not Washington, run their own elections under the structure this desk laid out in a recent explainer on federalism. If a state legislature or a citizen ballot initiative adopts RCV, that is the system working as designed — a local choice about local administration, not a federal mandate imposed from outside. Conservatives who object to RCV being forced on a state by court order or federal statute have a real complaint. Conservatives who object to a state choosing it through its own legislature or voters have a weaker one, and Cato's headline is implicitly making that distinction.
What should conservative voters watch for next?
The honest answer is that trust in any voting method flows from trust in the people counting it. The dispute this fall over whether a Wisconsin judge's license should be suspended over her conduct in office, still pending before the state's supreme court, is a reminder that institutional legitimacy, not ballot mechanics, is usually the real fight underneath election disputes. RCV will not fix that problem, and it will not create it either. Cato's case that conservatives should drop reflexive opposition to RCV is worth taking seriously on federalism grounds. Whether it should be adopted in any given state is still, correctly, a decision for that state to make — and for its voters to audit.
Artiglio is A coming-soon iPhone chief of staff for briefings and drafts. Not on the App Store yet.
Questions
What is ranked choice voting?
Ranked choice voting lets voters rank candidates in order of preference; if no one wins a majority, the last-place candidate is eliminated and those votes shift to voters' next choice until someone reaches 50 percent.
Why do some conservatives oppose ranked choice voting?
Common objections center on who controls ballot design and tabulation, slower certification during multi-round counts, and distrust of election administration rather than the ranking method itself.